Ivar KJELBERG
COMSOL Multiphysics(r) fan, retired, former "Senior Expert" at CSEM SA (CH)
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 decades ago
19.10.2009, 17:44 GMT-4
Hi
I get always slightly confused with the 2*pi*r multipicand to apply to axisymmetric models therefore I always check out my cases on some simple geometries.
Most source term for a volume is defines as W/m^3, this should then take into the account the 2*pi*r t give a homogenious source, even f r=0 on the axis, when defining the source on a surface (of revolution) in axisymmetry.
If you intend to apply a surface source on the radial edge (of revolution), you must define it as W/m^2 and again I believe this should take into account the case r=0 correctly.
COMSOL behaves slightly differenly in Structural 2D axisymmetry, where you have the option to multiply by 2*pi*r with a "click setting" which changes the Force load case units from N/m (respective to the edge) to N/m^2 (when you consider the edge as a surface by revolution).
so for me:
, subdomain = volume = represented as a surface*2*pi*r in axisymmetry = [W/m^3] (and W=J/s)
, and
, boundary = surface = represented as an edge*2*pi*r in axisymmetry = [W/m^2]
Hope this helps, pls check carefully
Good luck
Ivar
Hi
I get always slightly confused with the 2*pi*r multipicand to apply to axisymmetric models therefore I always check out my cases on some simple geometries.
Most source term for a volume is defines as W/m^3, this should then take into the account the 2*pi*r t give a homogenious source, even f r=0 on the axis, when defining the source on a surface (of revolution) in axisymmetry.
If you intend to apply a surface source on the radial edge (of revolution), you must define it as W/m^2 and again I believe this should take into account the case r=0 correctly.
COMSOL behaves slightly differenly in Structural 2D axisymmetry, where you have the option to multiply by 2*pi*r with a "click setting" which changes the Force load case units from N/m (respective to the edge) to N/m^2 (when you consider the edge as a surface by revolution).
so for me:
, subdomain = volume = represented as a surface*2*pi*r in axisymmetry = [W/m^3] (and W=J/s)
, and
, boundary = surface = represented as an edge*2*pi*r in axisymmetry = [W/m^2]
Hope this helps, pls check carefully
Good luck
Ivar