Discussion Closed This discussion was created more than 6 months ago and has been closed. To start a new discussion with a link back to this one, click here.

Plotting particle direction vs. position in a plane

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Hello,
I have traced particles in an electrostatic field.
Is it possible to create a 2D plot, which contains a specified pair of values (for example (vx,x)) of the particles on a cut plane? That is, for each particle, put a point into this 2D plot, which is the vx and x of the particle when crossing the specified cut plane.
Thank you
Daniel

3 Replies Last Post 04.11.2016, 08:59 GMT-4

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 1 decade ago 10.11.2014, 04:05 GMT-5
I am trying to understand how Poincare Map and Phase Portrait work. Correct me if I am wrong:
1) Poincare map: one defines a cut plane, and the coordinates of the crossing point of the particles with this plane are shown. One can not change it to any other expression.
2) Phase portrait: One can define what quantities (such as position of the particle, velocity components, etc) should be plotted, but only at a given *time*

Can these two be combined in some way? I would like to plot (vy/vx,x) not at a fixed time, but on a cut-plane. Is it possible in some way?
I am trying to understand how Poincare Map and Phase Portrait work. Correct me if I am wrong: 1) Poincare map: one defines a cut plane, and the coordinates of the crossing point of the particles with this plane are shown. One can not change it to any other expression. 2) Phase portrait: One can define what quantities (such as position of the particle, velocity components, etc) should be plotted, but only at a given *time* Can these two be combined in some way? I would like to plot (vy/vx,x) not at a fixed time, but on a cut-plane. Is it possible in some way?

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 8 years ago 03.11.2016, 08:54 GMT-4
Hi,

I actually have the same problem and like to know, if a solution came up during the last two years.

I need a poincare map (I guess it is a line) in a 2D geometry (rotationaly symmetric) to get the position, the velocity and the time, when a particle cuts that line.
Since it is 1D, I guess I need a 1D plot group. But then I don't have the option for a poincaré map.

Cheers,
Gero
Hi, I actually have the same problem and like to know, if a solution came up during the last two years. I need a poincare map (I guess it is a line) in a 2D geometry (rotationaly symmetric) to get the position, the velocity and the time, when a particle cuts that line. Since it is 1D, I guess I need a 1D plot group. But then I don't have the option for a poincaré map. Cheers, Gero

Christopher Boucher COMSOL Employee

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 8 years ago 04.11.2016, 08:59 GMT-4
Hi Gero, you need to use the "Intersection Point 2D" data set to define a cut line, then use a 1D Plot Group with the Particle plot type. I attach a simple model (made with v5.2a update 2) which does this. You can visualize the cut line by going to the Intersection Point 2D data set and clicking Plot. The 1D plot "Particle Position vs. Velocity" plots the particle position vs. velocity when the cut line is reached and the color represents the time when the particles reached the cut line.

The Intersection Point 2D data set was introduced in V5.2a, so you will need the latest release. There is also a 3D Intersection Point data set which can be used to plot phase portraits of particles on a given cut plane.

Chris
Hi Gero, you need to use the "Intersection Point 2D" data set to define a cut line, then use a 1D Plot Group with the Particle plot type. I attach a simple model (made with v5.2a update 2) which does this. You can visualize the cut line by going to the Intersection Point 2D data set and clicking Plot. The 1D plot "Particle Position vs. Velocity" plots the particle position vs. velocity when the cut line is reached and the color represents the time when the particles reached the cut line. The Intersection Point 2D data set was introduced in V5.2a, so you will need the latest release. There is also a 3D Intersection Point data set which can be used to plot phase portraits of particles on a given cut plane. Chris

Note that while COMSOL employees may participate in the discussion forum, COMSOL® software users who are on-subscription should submit their questions via the Support Center for a more comprehensive response from the Technical Support team.